French court rules against Nintendo in DS flash cart case, suggests platform should be more open to developers
We have just heard that Nintendo has today lost a major court case against the Divineo group in the main court of Paris. Nintendo originally took the group to court over DS flash carts, however the judge today has ruled against Nintendo and suggested that they are purposely locking out developers from their consoles and things should be more like Windows where ANYONE can develop any application if they wish to.
The ramifications of this are huge, as it indicates that flash carts are actually legal. Moroever, it could have bigger implications for developers and the like because Nintendo is deemed to be ‘illegally’ protecting their system by locking users out. Therefore, developers should not actually require separate development kits and should just be able to develop applications as they wish on retail versions of Nintendo’s consoles.
And on a final note, this truly was a HUGE court case, up in the main court of Paris France and seems likely to be relevant to the whole of Europe.
Essentially, if people have to ‘hack’ the system and use Flash Carts to do develop, then it’s all fine because Nintendo has left them with little other choice and the system should not be protected in such a restrictive way.
A step in the right direction though I don’t support making the protection of the system from ‘unauthorized’ software illegal. The provider should be able to lock out arbitrary code but owners additionally should be free to attempt to crack that protection.
Such as the Datel case against Microsoft. Microsoft has every right to ban unlicensed 3rd party memory cards (actually they ban access to Xbox Live if one is found)… but Datel equally should be legally allowed to impersonate legit memory cards so long as the customer is not told it’s legit.