… and it’s things like this that make it impossible for me back the ACLU
In my inbox today:
Dear ACLU Supporter,
Negotiations on the final health care bill pick up speed this week. As you may know, anti-choice forces in Congress have used this legislation as a vehicle for advancing their agenda.We must make sure that the final bill will protect reproductive freedom, not put it in peril.
Tell Sen. Frank R. Lautenberg and Sen. Robert ‘Bob’ Menendez and Rep. Steven ‘Steve’ R. Rothman to protect women’s access to abortion in health care reform.
Health care reform should improve people’s lives. That’s why we have to make the most of our last opportunity to insist that health care reform should improve women’s health and lives — not interfere in their ability to get the health care they need.
Representative Bart Stupak and other architects of the severe restrictions on women’s health in both the House and Senate bills are campaigning hard, threatening to derail health care legislation altogether if anyone tampers with the severe restrictions they forced into both bills. Even our allies in Congress are feeling pressure. That’s why it’s so urgent that you take action today.
Both bills stigmatize abortion coverage and ignore the reality that abortion services are basic health care for women.
Tell your members of Congress that Stupak-style restrictions must not be part of any final legislation that goes to President Obama’s desk.
Anti-choice forces are working round-the-clock to keep severe abortion restrictions in the health care bill. We have to work just as hard to get those restrictions out.
Negotiations on a final bill are happening now.
Please act immediately to insist on health reforms that will protect reproductive freedom, not put it in peril.
Thank you for standing with us.
Sincerely,
Vania Leveille
ACLU Legislative Counsel
- Women’s “reproductive freedom” is not in peril as a result of the upcoming bill.
- I seriously doubt the bill will “interfere in their [the women] ability to get health care they need.” It will likely require them to pay for it explicitly.
- Health care reform should improve people’s lives. I find it sad the ACLU is incapiple of recognizing that this or any similiar bill will do nothing of the sort. The health care problem stems from government intervention. Continuing the fascistic takeover of health care by corporations and the government is not the right solution. Reversing those interventions which create the problems are.
- Abortion services are in no way a “basic health care” for women. According to a quick Google search there are 4.0945 abortions per 1,000 people in the United states. Of those 1,000, 508 are women (50.8% of population). Therefore, assuming no woman has more then one abortion, 4.0945/508 = .00806 or .8% of women “require” abortion services.
I appreciate some of the actions taken by the ACLU, including the NYCLU helping me with my arrest and upcoming court date, but things like this are completely contrary to any form of liberty I’m a subscriber of. The government has no role, morally or constitutionally, in health care or insurance.



