Local Racial Profiling?
Posted on June 18th, 2009 at 9:53am by bosco Tags: 4th Amendment, racial profiling, racism, traffic enforcementAn article was published today by Donald Roscoe Brown that details how he was pulled over and questioned for no apparent reason. He believes he was profiled because he was black. I’ve seen many people pulled over at the same circle, in fact a friend of mine received a ticket there for not having registration. It’s a pretty well known police hangout and they will pull you over without justification. Interestingly enough the author of the article spends a lot of time in Trenton municipal court since he works as a lawyer in Ewing. His familiarity with the court system and laws makes the article even more insightful. Here are some excerpts:
The officer then looked at my license, registration and insurance card and politely returned them to me in about 30 seconds. I initially felt perturbed and offended, realizing that I had been stopped without what we lawyer-types refer to as either “reasonable suspicion” or “probable cause.” Realizing further that the landmark l979 United States Supreme Court decision in Delaware vs. Prouse has for the ensuing 20 years disallowed law enforcement officers from stopping motor vehicles for the sole purpose of ascertaining the validity of the operators’ driving credentials, I could not help but conclude that, but for my blackness, I probably would not have been stopped in Lawrence Township in late May.
That the attending officer thought I “might” not be wearing a seat belt was not a sufficient justification for stopping me after only seeing me for all of about five seconds. If that was indeed the officer’s suspicion, he certainly could have — and, in fact, should have — followed me for a reasonable distance until he was able to better determine whether my seat belt was engaged. Such a period of surveillance would have constituted excellent police work.
As reported by The New York Times, New York City police officers made more than 170,000 stops on their streets in the first three months of 2009, the most for any quarter in the eight years since the department began recording such data. The percentage of stops that yielded arrests or summonses, however, has remained consistent at a lowly 10 percent. Particularly troubling was that the vast majority of those stops (144,000) were of blacks and Latinos. As such, racial profiling by municipal police officers, regardless of whether they be situated in Lawrence Township or New York City, is a practice that needs — finally — to be put to rest.
Now I disagree that following someone to ascertain whether or not they are wearing their seat belt would be “excellent police work”. Preventing violent crimes would be excellent police work. If someone wants to endanger their own life, that’s fine with me. I do however support Mr. Brown in his belief that this traffic stop was unreasonable. Most of the stops at that circle are.





