Police cracking down on NYC subway musicians
Are the strings attached to subway strumming getting tighter?
Veteran transit musicians say police harassment has grown to disturbing levels in recent months, leading some to fear that independent performers could be driven out of the subways.
“It’s a game to drive you crazy,” said Mark “Shakerleg” Nicosia, 34, a subway drummer who has been ticketed repeatedly this year.
The musicians, also known as buskers, report they have been banned from certain areas of the platforms and have been ushered out of the subways even before setting up their equipment. While anyone can legally play in the subway, artists suspect police are targeting musicians who have not been officially sanctioned by the MTA under its Music Under New York program.
“It’s a blitz. I’ve been written up in so many ways,” said Ron Wingate, 43, a guitarist who has performed in the subways for eight years.
Playing in the subways was illegal for decades, but a judge reversed the ban in 1985. NYC Transit allows performers to play acoustic on subway platforms and with amps on mezzanines. Volumes can’t be “excessive” and artists must not block pedestrians or play near construction, according to transit rules.
More often then not these musicians are harmless. I walk past at least 3 a day. There are some I really enjoy like the accordion player in the tunnel between Port Authority and Times Square. Others are awfully annoying… but what are you going to do? It’s a public area. Well it’s government owned/subsidized… often you will be told by the NYPD and PAPD that it’s in fact private property. No real owner means clear and fast rules are impossible without conflict.
I wish the musicians luck in combating this crackdown and will try to film any ticketing events I come across. I’ve been harassed by the PAPD for supposedly creating a disturbance before in Grand Central yet musicians can blast arbitrary music and Christians and Jews for Jesus can hand out literature which mostly ends up on the ground and yell about “the Lord” and the end times. Due to that difference I always used them as examples of the ridiculousness of the claim we were causing an out of the ordinary disturbance. Should the NYPD/PAPD/MTA continue to crack down on musicians and others my counter example will be lost… though I will likely gain allies.


