Robber spared jail because of fear of prison
Posted on June 14th, 2009 at 10:44am by bile Tags: attack, childhood abuse, court, death, jail, judge, Judge Anthony Cleary, Keith Hopkins, manslaughter, UK, Winifred PhippsKeith Hopkins attacked Winifred Phipps, grabbing her bag and dragging her across the ground until she had to let go.
Since then she has worred about leaving her home and has to walk a different way into town because she cannot bear to be reminded of that day.
But Judge Anthony Cleary said he had to “exercise a degree of mercy” when sentencing Hopkins because he had suffered a number of traumatic events while in prison on remand.
Instead of sending him to prison, he handed him a community sentence for two years.
Mrs Phipps, of Leamington, Warks., branded the sentence a joke and slammed the judge for being too soft.
She said: “I’m very disappointed with what’s happened here.
“There are people that have had a lot harder lives than him and not done the terrible things he has.
“I was very surprised to hear he’d got away with not getting a jail sentence.
“My nerves are completely shot to pieces after what’s happened.
“I couldn’t go anywhere by myself and often have to go to the doctors for my aches and pains.
“Because it happened near there I still can’t go there alone.
“My husband Frank always comes with me and we even have to take a different route to town because I can’t bear to be reminded of that day.”
Warwick Crown Court heard Hopkins, 27, had suffered psychological problems brought on by a number of factors including an attack by others while on remand.
He also suffered childhood abuse and was haunted by the death of a friend he stabbed during the drunken and drug-fuelled argument he was convicted of manslaughter for in 2003.
Judge Cleary said: “While on remand in prison something terrified you.
“No-one would want anyone to be subjected to such terror as was clear to me in that earlier occasion.
“I do not consider you to be wicked or evil.
“It is appropriate to exercise a degree of mercy in your case.”
In a resititution based system this guy likely wouldn’t be held in prison. He would have paid off his debts to the family and friends of his victim and let go. Without further information it sounds as if it was likely prison that caused him to become a petty criminal. Prison and jail aren’t designed to reabilitate or even provide an enviroment for the criminal (or so called criminal) to pay off the debts for their crime. It’s a melting pot of some of the worst in society and they keep adding in more people, both true criminals and not, and acting as if things will get better for them. That they won’t be worse off, that we all won’t be worse off, when they get out.
Create a loser pays, restitution based system and get rid of the war on drugs and much of our criminal problems and court abuse would disappear.


















